Main Menu

Home
Audio/Video Library
About Us
ACNA
Budget
Building for Christ
Cathedral
Clergy Directory
Church Directory
Contact Us
Deacons
Deaneries
Diocesan Office
Diocesan Structure
GAFCON
Global South
Parochial Report
Staff Directory
Our Seal
Visiting Bishop
Bishop Lawrence
About Us
Statement of Faith
Employment
Job Openings
Anglican Partnerships
Bishop Lawrence
Bishop's Schedule
About Bishop Lawrence
Bishop's Messages
Committees
Anglican Missional Partnerships
Commission on Ministry
Diocesan Council
Ecclesiastical Court
Evangelism
Finance Department
Liturgy and Worship
Provincial Affiliation
Standing Committee
Stewardship
Stewardship 2
Communication
Enewsletter
Jubilate Deo
Photo Gallery
Submission Guidelines
Photo Albums
Treasurers' Tips
Contact Us
Staff Directory
Submissions
Clergy Directory
Church Directory
Search for Church
Contact Us
Convention Information
Convention News
Convention Journals
Convention Archives
Convention Audio and Video Files
Donate Now
Governance
Constitution
Canons
Diocesan Council
Standing Committee
Trustees
Statement of Faith
Institutions
Anglican Leadership Institute
St. Christopher
Canterbury House
Porter Gaud School
SC Episcopal Home
Voorhees College
York Place
Job Openings
Legal Defense Fund
Legal News & Media
Ministries & Departments
1670 Legacy
Addiction Recovery
Anglicans for Life
Anglican Relief and Development Fund
Brothrhd of St. Andrew
Clergy Spouse
Christian Faith Formation
Young Adult Ministry
Cursillo
Daughters of the King
Faith Alive
Hispanic Ministry
HIV/AIDS Ministry
Kairos Prison Ministry
Order of Saint Vincent
Social Ministries
St. Luke - Physician
Stewardship
Women's Ministries
Grandparenting
Men's Ministry
Women's Ministry
Youth Ministry
News & Events
Jubilate Deo
Submission Guidelines
Latest News
Recent Events
Clergy News
Job Openings
Photo Gallery
Media Room
Diocesan Calendar
Reflections on Emanuel AME Shootings
Audio/Video Library
Resources - Clergy
Cursillo Application
Marriage
Ordination Process
Supply Clergy
Sabbatical Guidelines
Parochial Report Forms
Visitation Customary
Pension Information
Job Openings
Benefits & Compensation
Child Abuse Prevention
Commission on Ministry
Deacons
Resources - General
Background Check
Diocesan Forms
Diocesan Payroll Plan
Disaster Preparedness
Hurricane Preparedness
Letter of Agreement Rector
Medical Insurance
Marriage
Ordination Process
Parish Audits
Parochial Report
Parochial Report Forms
Prayer Calendar
Risk Management
Stewardship
Vestry Handbook
Safeguarding God's Children
Treasurer's Office
Dio. Audited Fin.l Stmts.
Budget
Clergy Compensation
Clergy Salary Worksheet
Declaration of Intent
Employee Classification
Parish Audits
Pledge Report
Sample Housing Resolutions
Treasurers' Tips
Housing Allowance Worksheet
Overtime Rules
Parochial Report Forms
Make a Payment

Who's Online Now

We have 126 guests and no members online

COLUMBIA, S.C. (September 25, 2017) – Today the Diocese of South Carolina (Diocese) filed our Replies, to the Return by The Episcopal Church (TEC) to our motions for recusal and rehearing in the South Carolina Supreme Court, regarding its recent ruling in Appellate Case No. 2015-000622.  

Statement by the Rev. Canon Jim Lewis:   

“Today’s filings by the Diocese of South Carolina address the property law issues at the heart of this case. TEC failed to establish a trust interest in property, of any sort, that can be recognized under 300 years of existing South Carolina legal precedent.  And to claim such an interest now is to grant TEC favored status against the Diocese and its parishes, establishing one church body over another. This is inconsistent with opinions of the United States Supreme Court that truly “neutral” principles of state law must be applied as they would be in any other case.

Further, the timeliness of our request for recusal is not an issue before an appellate court.    The public confidence in and the credibility of the Court is!  The most effective way to assure both is the recusal of Justice Hearn and the vacating of her opinion.  A ruling free from conflict of interest is not a right that can be waived.”





The Diocese also provided the following list of additional details:

•    In 2012, the Diocese of South Carolina, along with 50 of its congregations voted by an 80% margin to disassociate from The Episcopal Church.  In a complicated and sharply divided ruling consisting of five separate opinions, the S.C. Supreme Court appeared to rule on August 2 this year that parishes which had “acceded” to the national church are subject to a trust interest in their property by (TEC).  

•    Conclusion to today’s Reply in Support of Motion to Recuse:  “The depth of Justice Hearn’s connection to this case warrants her disqualification pursuant to Canon 3E to ensure the promotion of public confidence in the integrity of the Court and in this decision.  Justice Hearn should recuse herself and the Court should vacate her opinion.”

•    Conclusion to our Reply in Support of Motion to Rehear:   "There is no basis under this Court’s or the United States Supreme Court’s precedents or South Carolina trust law for the outcome that the Court reached based on the principles the Court stated that it applied …  The result reached by the majority… is incompatible with South Carolina law."  

•    Over one hundred ten clergy from around the state of South Carolina, representing 10 different denominations, have come together to express their support for the Diocese and their concern for the Constitutional issues raised by our Supreme Court ruling.  “If one religious group can be treated in this fashion today, there is good cause for concern that others may fare no better in the future.”

•    The Rev. Jeff Miller, rector of St. Philip’s, Charleston, the mother-church of the Diocese, rightly describes the consequence of the existing ruling.  “Religious freedom in these cherished, sacred spaces dating back to 1680 will be denied, and these properties taken away.  This freedom will be denied, not because tens of thousands of parishioners have changed their beliefs, but rather because they have not.  Members of St. Philip’s and the other Diocesan congregations adhere to the faith of their fathers and grandfathers, of great-grandfathers and great-great-grandfathers, the historic faith of Christians as practiced for 2,000 years.”  

•    The Justice in this ruling who provided the deciding vote is a member of a TEC parish, Diocese and its national church, who would be the beneficiaries of a nearly $500 million property windfall if the current ruling stands.  That is a massive conflict of interest.  It is the responsibility of the judge, under the South Carolina Code of Judicial Conduct, to reveal that issue, not for a party in the case to challenge the propriety of their actions.  

•    The expert affidavit testimonies of Nathan M. Crystal, Professor and Adjunct Professor of Ethics at the University of South Carolina and NYU Schools of Law and Lawrence J. Fox, Professor of Ethics at Yale University are unanimous in concluding the due process rights of the Diocese of South Carolina have been violated by these actions and the only appropriate response is for this Justice to be recused from further participation in this case and their opinion vacated.  

•    As Justice Kittredge noted in his dissenting opinion, “The message is clear for churches in South Carolina that are affiliated in any manner with a national organization and have never lifted a finger to transfer control or ownership of their property—if you think your property ownership is secure, think again.”

•    Former Chief Justice Jean Toal, in her dissenting opinion, had this observation to make about its impact on the property rights of the Diocese of South Carolina.  “The lead opinion in this case is nothing less than judicial sanction of the confiscation of church property masquerading as an attempt to promulgate a new deference rule for determining title in this matter.” 

 LINKS:  

A copy of today’s filed Replies can be found here:
   http://www.diosc.com/sys/images/documents/tec/2017-9-25-reply-to-petition-rehearing.pdf
   http://www.diosc.com/sys/images/documents/tec/2017-9-25-reply-to-motion-to-recuse.pdf

A copy of the Diocese’s filed Petition, Motion and Affidavits can be found here:
   http://www.diosc.com/sys/images/documents/tec/2017-09-01-petition-for-rehearing.pdf
   http://www.diosc.com/sys/images/documents/tec/2017-09-01-motion-to-recuse-and-vacate.pdf
   http://www.diosc.com/sys/images/documents/tec/crystal_affidavit_2017_8_29.pdf    
   http://www.diosc.com/sys/images/documents/tec/fox_affidavit_2017_8_30.PDF 

Supreme Court’s Current Ruling and Video of Oral Arguments:
   http://www.sccourts.org/opinions/HTMLFiles/SC/27731.pdf 
   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yu8CShvWcC8&feature=youtu.be

Judge Goodstein’s Orders from Trial Court:
   http://www.diosc.com/sys/images/documents/tec/15_2_3_final_order.pdf 
   http://www.diosc.com/sys/images/documents/tec/goodstein_denies_reconsider_2_23_25.pdf
 
South Carolina Code of Judicial Conduct
   Canon 2 - http://www.sccourts.org/courtreg/displayRule.cfm?ruleID=501.0&subRuleID=Canon%202&ruleType=APP 
   Canon 3 - http://www.sccourts.org/courtreg/displayRule.cfm?ruleID=501.0&subRuleID=Canon%203&ruleType=APP 

History of the Case and The Diocese of South Carolina:
   http://www.diosc.com/sys/legal-media 

A recent statement by over 110 clergy of 10 difference denominations affirming our legal concerns:
   https://www.palmettofamily.org/diocese-supporters/     

The Statement by the Rector of St. Philip’s, Charleston regarding the potential impact of this ruling:
   http://www.postandcourier.com/opinion/commentary/court-ruling-imperils-freedom-to-worship-sanctions-confiscation/article_45d05da6-9a1c-11e7-8bdd-db20e560504a.html

 

Let's Connect!

Diocesan Seal and Facebook Logo

Visit Bishop's Blog
Sign up for our e-newsletter.
View past issues of e-newsletter.

Latest News

Daffodil Garden Planted in Honor of the Rev. Bob H...
Wed, January 25, 2017

Fr. Bob Horowitz was surprised by the St. Jude's Church family by the planting of a daffodil garden in his honor after services on December 11

Organiz [ ... ]

latest news+ Full Story
Other Articles